Judge the Judge: Building LLM Evaluators That Actually Work with GEPA — Mahmoud Mabrouk, Agenta AI
Apr 10, 2026 · 40:51
Mahmoud Mabrouk, co-founder of Agenta AI, demonstrates how to build calibrated LLM-as-a-judge evaluators using the GEPA prompt optimization algorithm, arguing that miscalibrated evals are worse than none. He walks through a practical workflow for a customer support agent using the TaoBench airline dataset, covering metric design, data annotation, and GEPA-based optimization. The seed judge achieved 61% accuracy; after optimization, accuracy rose to 74% with reduced bias, though the judge still struggled to fully learn the complex policy. Mabrouk shares key lessons: start with a seed prompt biased toward compliance, use larger models for refinement, overfit to training data first, and beware of high token costs.
